ESG

Norilsk's spill bill points to mounting ESG risk, says Fitch

Spill bodes ill for other commodity companies operating in Russian Arctic

Staff reporter

This article is 5 years old. Images might not display.

"We believe that the importance of the environmental factor will continue to increase as new, previously unanticipated environmental risks start to materialise," said Fitch.

Norilsk's spill, which Greenpeace described as one of the biggest oil product accidents to ever have occurred in the Russian Arctic, saw about 21,000 tonnes of fuel leaked into rivers and subsoil near the city of Norilsk on May 29.

Fitch said the scale of Norilsk's damages, which it estimated would equate to a quarter of the company's 2020 EBITDA, was comparable only with Vale's tailings dam collapse in 2019. Vale paid out US$1.4 billion and had US$3.4 billion of provisions outstanding at the end of June.

The fact that Norilsk pointed to thawing permafrost as the trigger for the accident bodes ill for other commodity-focused companies operating in Russia, said the ratings agency.

"Almost two-thirds of Russian territory is in permafrost areas, and this is where many commodity companies operate (including gas producers Novatek and Gazprom).

Global heating will require "significant spending on infrastructure and stricter focus on environmental controls and safety".

"While Novatek's Yamal LNG mega project has propelled the company from a niche Russian natural gas producer into a global LNG player with a 5% share of the global LNG market, it cost the company US$27 billion and required unique technical solutions. It was built on a large number of piles of different sizes and shapes not used on such a scale before to support its stability in permafrost," said Fitch.

Expert-led Insights reports and Analytics tools built on robust data, rigorous analysis and expert commentary covering mining Risk, Projects, ESG, Leadership, and Investor Sentiment.

Expert-led Insights reports and Analytics tools built on robust data, rigorous analysis and expert commentary covering mining Risk, Projects, ESG, Leadership, and Investor Sentiment.

editions

Investor Sentiment Insights 2026

Discover what investors have planned for mining in 2026 in our industry-leading survey

editions

World Risk Insights 2025 (feat. MineHutte ratings)

A detailed analysis of mining investment risks across 120 jurisdictions globally, assessed across six risk categories and an industrywide survey.

editions

ESG Index 2025: Benchmarking the Future of Sustainable Mining

The ESG Index provides an in-depth evaluation of the ESG performance of 60+ of the world’s largest mining companies. It assesses companies across 10 weighted indicators within 6 essential ESG pillars.

editions

Leadership Insights 2025

Leadership Insights reveals key trends in priority mining issues through interviews with 15+ top mining company executives and an industrywide survey.